I really liked the concept behind this course. Offering a class to teach somewhat-advanced topics in quantum physics, for people that aren’t (or aren’t planning to become) experts in the field, is a fantastic idea. That being said, I personally found a few issues with the class.
First of all, the “about” section describes it as: “An introduction to quantum physics with emphasis on topics at the frontiers of research…”. However, in no shape or form this is an introductory course to the subject. I think someone without any previous exposure to quantum mechanics will find the material very difficult to follow. For instance, concepts like operators, Dirac notation, time evolution, commutators are used in the first few lectures without a formal introduction. I think that perhaps having some exposure to introductory concepts in quantum mechanics (like in my case) is probably a prerequisite to really be able to get through this course and make it enjoyable. I believe that if I hadn't previously taken another intro course to quantum mechanics, I would have most likely given up after the first lecture.
Second of all, although the first half of the course is very well organized and self-contained, the second half is extremely hard to follow and requires a good amount of extra work to really understand the material. It isn’t necessarily that the material is harder, it is just not explained very well. Also, all quizzes are quite difficult, but the material covered in the first 4 weeks is enough to provide the tools required to solve its homework. Now, for weeks 5 through 8, you are probably going to spend twice (or three times) as long solving the problems; particularly the ones for week 7.
Lastly, I think there is a problem in the way the final exam was structured. The instructors decided to split it into two separate parts, one with 10 question and one with only 6 questions. In order to pass the class, you have to get at least 70% on each of these separately, and you only get one attempt. That means that, in the second part of the final, you can only get one out only six questions wrong, otherwise you fail the whole course! Furthermore, this second part corresponds to the material covered in the second half of the course (which is harder to follow), and there are several question that are NOT multiple option; you actually have to input a number with significant digits and exponents as an answer. This means that, if you get one wrong answer, and let’s say make one single typing mistake inputing another of these answers, you will fail the WHOLE course. I did manage to pass the exam only getting the last question wrong, but the amount of stress I had at this point after realizing I could only make one mistake, and having payed for a potential certificate, and dedicating weeks of my time taking the course very seriously, was ridiculous. I really hope they fix this.
por Anna C•
too difficult for beginners
por Cooper T•
This course is certainly too difficult for beginners, however, students with prior education in Q.M., Calculus and generalized physics will have a great but challenging time with this course.
por Prof ( .•
Excellent.Informative and ell explained by resource person.I enjoyed very much and learn a lot.
por Fernando M•
I love the fact this course was orientated in base of original quantum physics papers. I love the Feyman formulation chapter, I would enjoy a full course about it.
por Lucio L G•
4 options every 60 days, and the final two tests gives one shot only? Come on!! Besides that, great course, a hard one
por narasimha s a•
This is quite a rigorous course ,taught me the advanced concepts Clear insight into path integrals, gauge transformation ,quantum statistics." CONCEPTS, PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS & NUMERICAL COMPUTATIONS are in PHASE"
por Emin G•
Very challenging course. The lectures are confusing and superficial, but the exercises and the exam problems are very interesting (and importantly are all correct).
por Brian B•
Not what I was looking for
por Soumyajit M•
Excellent course. Learnt a lot.
por Inoka k•
best and excellent course
por Amit K P•
por Ermanno G•
Way to complicated and fast for beginners who are just trying to understand the basics.
por Isabella E•
Very good course for students who have the basis of quantum mechanics and want to explore the quantum physics! All the topics are very interesting. I also appreciate that the course is research oriented and always remark when talk about current subjects. Well done to all the professors of the course!